1. Sports

Discuss in my forum

Bloodied Cotto Edges Clottey by Split Decision

Did Clottey Get Robbed by Judges?

By , About.com Guide

Updated June 15, 2009
Miguel Cotto (33-1) retained his WBO welterweight title with a twelve round split decision over Joshua Clottey (35-2) at Madison Square Garden in New York City. Cotto surprisingly dropped the durable Clottey with a jab late in the first round. An accidental clash of heads in round three opened up a nasty gash over Cotto’s right eye. The cut was never really brought under control by Cotto’s corner and the blood appeared to bother Cotto over the remaining nine rounds. To his credit, Cotto never looked to take the easy way out and complain to the referee about not being able to see so that the fight would go to the scorecards.

Clottey faced his own adversity when he appeared to injure his right knee or ankle when he got tossed to the ground by Cotto. Clottey also struggled with his footing throughout the fight as the canvas was obviously slick from the large, freshly painted Tecate logos all over the ring. It’s ridiculous how frequently this is an issue in big fights when it could so easily be avoided.

Cotto showed tremendous heart but it was actually Clottey who was the sharper, more accurate ring technician in most rounds. Clottey could have been a bit more active at times and certainly did not fight with sufficient urgency in the final round. Nevertheless, he did enough to come away with no less than a draw ... but this is boxing and Clottey was not going to win a decision against Cotto in front of a full house of Cotto supporters on the eve of the Puerto Rican Day parade. No shot. The scores were 115-112, 116-111 for Cotto, 114-113 for Clottey. The 116-111 turned in by judge Don Trella was way off the mark -- there’s no way Clottey only won four rounds.

Punch Stats: Total Punches: Cotto - 179 of 723 (25%); Clottey - 222 of 622 (36%).

After the fight, Clottey pleaded for a rematch but it’s more likely that Cotto will seek a big money bout with either Manny Pacquiao, who watch the fight from ringside, or Floyd Mayweather Jr..

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.